SLS-222 · Lesson 11 of 12 · 22 min

Competing against a lower price

▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.

On Thursday, November 12, two days after Prairie Valley had selected Ridgeline for its managed print contract, Rob used the value desk for a review of the fall's price battles. Ridgeline had won Prairie Valley at 66,000 dollars a year against an incumbent bid of 62,900. It had held its 48,000-dollar price at Keystone against an integrator's 41,500. And it had lost a dental clinic's furniture refresh to a cheaper online seller. "Three deals, three lower prices," Rob said. "We won two and lost one. I want to know why each went the way it did."

Every seller with a product that is not the cheapest faces a lower price sooner or later. The responses available are few, and the most common one, matching the price, is usually the worst. This lesson brings together the ideas of the course into a way of handling the moment.

First, understand what the lower price means

When a buyer mentions a lower price, it can mean very different things, and the right response depends on which. Rob's first rule was to find out before reacting.

Five things a lower price can mean.
What the lower price may meanSignsUseful response
A real budget limitThe buyer cannot spend more than a fixed amountChange the scope, structure or timing to fit the budget
A genuine preference for the cheaper offerThe buyer sees the offers as equivalentShow the real differences, or accept that this buyer values price most
A negotiating tacticThe buyer wants a concession and is testing the sellerHold the price, explore what else matters, trade if anything
A request for helpThe buyer wants to choose the seller but needs a reason to give colleaguesGive the champion the comparison and the value case
A comparison of unequal offersThe offers differ in scope, service or termsCompare like with like, line by line

Questions do most of the work. "Help me understand what's included in their price." "If price were the same, which would you choose, and why?" "What would you need to see to justify the difference to your finance team?" Dale Petrie's answer to the second question about the integrator, "Yours, because of the booking", told Maya that the issue was justification, not preference, which is why the value argument in lesson 8 worked.

Compare like with like

Lower prices are often lower because they include less. A seller's first job is to put the two offers side by side on the same basis, without disparaging the competitor. Buyers respond badly to criticism of rivals, and false statements about a competitor can also be illegal as misleading representations, as SLS-150 explained. Facts, stated neutrally, are enough.

The Prairie Valley offers compared on the same basis (from the tender responses).
Prairie Valley managed printIncumbentRidgeline
Annual price62,900 dollars66,000 dollars
Service responseNext business dayFour business hours, with a loaner if a fix takes more than one business day
Technician in the areaFrom the city officeBased in the division's area three days a week
Toner orderingEach school orders separatelySingle automatic ordering for all sites
ReportingDivision totalBy school
Staff trainingAt installationTwo sessions per school per year

In Prairie Valley's case, the tender's scoring made the comparison formal. Price was worth 40 of 100 points, with the lowest price earning the full 40 and others scored in proportion.

Worked problem

What the higher price cost Ridgeline in the tender scoring

The tender awarded price points as 40 × (lowest price ÷ bidder's price). The incumbent's price of 62,900 dollars a year was the lowest. Ridgeline's best and final price was 66,000 dollars. How many price points did each receive, and how many did Ridgeline give up?

Show solution
  1. Incumbent: lowest price, so 40 points.
  2. \[\text{Ridgeline} = 40 \times \frac{62{,}900}{66{,}000} \approx 38.1 \text{ points}\]
  3. Points given up: 40 − 38.1 = about 1.9 of 100.

Answer: Ridgeline gave up about 1.9 points on price, out of 100. It won because it scored more than that above the incumbent on technical merit, service and implementation, which together were worth 50 points.

The scoring showed something Rob wanted everyone to remember. A price difference of about 5 in 100 cost less than 2 points out of 100. Matching the incumbent's price would have gained Ridgeline those 2 points and cost it 3,100 dollars a year for five years, about 15,500 dollars, on a contract that already ran at its minimum margin. Ridgeline's walk-away price, the lowest it would accept at its 22 in 100 minimum margin for multi-year public contracts, was 63,540 dollars; matching 62,900 would have gone below it.

Reframe to total value

When the offers really differ, the strongest response is to move the comparison from price to total cost or total value: the TCO of lesson 5, the EVC of lesson 8, or the risk of the cheaper option. The question to ask is what the cheaper option will cost the customer over the time it uses it. For Prairie Valley, the business manager's own concern was a printer failing in a school on an exam morning; next-day service meant a lost day, and Ridgeline's four-hour response with loaners addressed it directly. The value was in the customer's terms, not Ridgeline's.

Change the offer, not just the price

If the customer genuinely cannot or will not pay the higher price, there are better moves than cutting it.

Responses to a lower price that do not simply match it.
MoveHow it worksExample
Reduce the scopeRemove something to meet the budget, keeping the price of what remainsFour training rooms instead of six at Keystone
UnbundleOffer components separately so the customer pays only for what it valuesRooms without RoomFlow, booking added later
Change the structureSpread or shift payments without reducing the totalThe five-year lease from lesson 5
Offer good, better, bestLet the customer choose the level of value it wantsLesson 12's three training-center options
Trade a concessionGive something only in return for somethingA small discount for a longer term or a reference
Walk awayDecline a deal below the floorThe dental clinic's furniture refresh

Each of these keeps the link between price and value. A cut in price with nothing changed tells the customer that the first price was padded, and invites the same request next time. A smaller offer at a lower price tells the customer that the price reflects what it gets.

When to walk away

The deal Ridgeline lost was a furniture refresh for a dental office, about 12,400 dollars at Ridgeline's price. In early November, after the office manager stopped returning calls, Maya reached her and learned that the clinic had ordered similar desks and chairs online for about 18 in 100 less, with curbside delivery. Maya asked whether there was anything Ridgeline could do, and the answer was no: the price was the only criterion, and the order was placed.

Worked problem

The cost of matching the dental clinic's price

Ridgeline's quote was 12,400 dollars at a gross margin of 32 in 100. Matching a price 18 in 100 lower would have meant a price of 12,400 × 0.82. What would the gross profit and margin have been?

Show solution
  1. Cost: 12,400 × (1 − 0.32) = 8,432 dollars.
  2. Matched price: 12,400 × 0.82 = 10,168 dollars.
  3. Gross profit: 10,168 − 8,432 = 1,736 dollars.
  4. \[\text{Margin} = \frac{1{,}736}{10{,}168} \approx 0.171\]

Answer: Gross profit would have fallen from 3,968 dollars to 1,736, a margin of about 17 in 100, before delivery and installation, which Ridgeline includes and the online seller did not. After those costs the deal would have made almost nothing.

Rob's view was that the loss was the right result. The clinic valued price above everything else, Ridgeline's differences, delivery, installation and the long warranty, were worth little to this customer, and matching would have earned Ridgeline nearly nothing while teaching the clinic that its prices were negotiable by a fifth. Some customers are better served by a cheaper competitor, and recognizing them early saves everyone time. Maya closed the opportunity as lost with the reason recorded, which SLS-214 explained is how Ridgeline learns from its losses.

Holding the price with confidence

Holding a price is easier when the seller believes it is fair. That belief comes from the work of the whole course: understanding the customer's business, knowing what the differences are worth, knowing the seller's own margins and floors, and having a value case built on the customer's numbers. Sellers who have not done that work feel every price objection as an accusation. Sellers who have done it can say calmly, "Our price is higher, and here's what the difference buys you. If that isn't worth it to you, the other offer may be the better choice." Customers often respect that answer more than a quick discount.

Preparing for the price conversation

Rob's last piece of advice in the session was that most price battles are won or lost before the buyer mentions a competitor. A seller who walks into a negotiation without knowing its own numbers will improvise, and improvised concessions are usually expensive. He asked each account executive to prepare five figures before any significant price discussion, and to write them down where nobody at the customer could see them.

Five figures to prepare before a price discussion.
FigureWhat it meansPrairie Valley
Target priceThe price the seller expects to justify70,800 dollars a year, the first offer
Walk-away priceThe lowest acceptable price, from the minimum margin63,540 dollars a year at 22 in 100
The customer's alternativeWhat the customer will do if it does not choose the seller, and its priceThe incumbent at 62,900 dollars with next-day service
The value of the differenceWhat the seller's advantages are worth to this customerSame-day service across 15 sites; single ordering; school reports
Planned concessions and their costWhat the seller can give, and what each costsTwo training sessions per school (about 2,100 dollars a year); a lower price to 66,000

With these figures written down, the best and final offer in October was a decision rather than a scramble. Ridgeline moved from 70,800 to 66,000 dollars and added the training sessions, which kept its margin at about 22 in 100 and above the walk-away price. It did not go to 62,900, because that was below the floor and because the tender's scoring meant it did not need to.

Worked problem

Checking the best and final offer against the floor

Ridgeline's annual cost of delivering the Prairie Valley contract was about 49,560 dollars, plus about 2,100 dollars a year for the added training sessions. What was the margin at the best and final price of 66,000 dollars?

Show solution
  1. Total annual cost: 49,560 + 2,100 = 51,660 dollars.
  2. Gross profit: 66,000 − 51,660 = 14,340 dollars.
  3. \[\text{Margin} = \frac{14{,}340}{66{,}000} \approx 0.217\]

Answer: A margin of about 22 in 100, at the minimum Ridgeline accepted for multi-year public contracts. The training sessions were a concession with a known cost, chosen because the business manager had said staff training was a weakness of the current arrangement.

Procurement and the lower price

Professional buyers in procurement departments are trained to use competing prices as leverage. That is their job, and a seller should not resent it. Common procurement approaches include asking every bidder for its best price before discussing scope, presenting a competitor's price without its terms, setting deadlines to create urgency and asking for concessions on payment terms after the price is agreed. SLS-213 covered how to negotiate with procurement; the point here is how business acumen helps.

A seller who understands the buyer's own measures can often find a solution that satisfies procurement without a price cut. Procurement teams are frequently measured on savings against a budget or a previous price. A longer term with fixed prices, a cap on future increases, a rebate tied to volume or a lower total cost of ownership may count as savings in their system while protecting the seller's price. Prairie Valley's procurement officer, Colleen Sawatzky, needed to show the board a saving of at least 10 in 100 against the division's current spending of about 78,000 dollars a year. Ridgeline's 66,000 dollars was about 15 in 100 below that, which met her test even though it was not the lowest bid. Knowing her measure meant Ridgeline did not have to chase the incumbent's number.

Common mistakes

  • MistakeA lower competing price should be matched to keep the deal.

    InsteadFind out what the lower price means first; matching often loses margin without changing the decision.

  • MistakePointing out a competitor's weaknesses is the best defense.

    InsteadCompare like with like, neutrally; criticizing rivals annoys buyers and false claims can be illegal.

  • MistakeIf the customer will not pay, cut the price.

    InsteadReduce scope, unbundle, change the structure, offer options or trade a concession instead.

  • MistakeEvery lost deal is a failure.

    InsteadSome customers value price above everything; walking away from a deal below the floor can be the right result.

Summary and key terms

  • A lower competing price can mean a real budget limit, a genuine preference, a negotiating tactic, a request for help or a comparison of unequal offers, and the right response depends on which.
  • Questions reveal which it is.
  • Comparing offers like with like, neutrally, often shows that the lower price includes less.
  • In scored tenders, a modest price difference may cost few points.
  • Reframing to total cost, value or risk keeps the conversation on what the customer gets.
  • Better moves than cutting price include reducing scope, unbundling, changing the payment structure, offering good-better-best options and trading concessions.
  • Below the seller's floor, walking away can be the right decision.
  • Confidence in a price comes from knowing what it is worth.
Walk-away price
The lowest price a seller will accept on a deal, set by its minimum margin.
Like-for-like comparison
A side-by-side comparison of offers on the same scope, service and terms.
Reframing
Moving the comparison from price to total cost, value or risk.
Unbundling
Offering components of a bundle separately so the customer pays only for what it values.

Practice problems

Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.

  1. A tender scores price as 30 × (lowest ÷ bid). The lowest bid is 90,000 dollars and yours is 100,000. How many price points do you receive?

    Show answer

    30 × 0.9 = 27 points.

  2. Your quote is 20,000 dollars at a 30 in 100 margin. What gross profit remains if you match a price 10 in 100 lower?

    Show answer

    Cost 14,000; price 18,000; gross profit 4,000 dollars, down from 6,000.

  3. Give a question that helps you learn what a lower price really means to the buyer.

    Show answer

    For example: "If the prices were the same, which would you choose, and why?"

Lesson quiz · 5 questions

Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.

Take the quiz