SLS-110 · Lesson 6 of 12 · 19 min
Social influence, culture and reference groups
▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.
On a Sunday afternoon in October 2026, three people walked into Juniper & Pine together: a woman in her thirties, her husband and her mother. They were looking for a dining table. Aiden addressed most of his questions to the husband, who had spoken first, and showed him the extending tables. After twenty minutes, the mother quietly asked about a solid wood table with eight chairs. It emerged that the family hosted large Sunday dinners at the mother's house, that she would be paying, and that the couple were there mostly to help her choose. The table would be delivered to her home, not theirs. Aiden had spent twenty minutes selling to the wrong person.
No buyer decides alone. Even a purchase made by one person is shaped by family, friends, colleagues, online reviewers, the groups the buyer belongs to and the culture the buyer grew up in. This lesson looks at how those influences work and how a salesperson can respect them. It also introduces the principles of influence that the psychologist Robert Cialdini described, which appear throughout selling, and the ethical limits on using them.
Reference groups
A reference group is any group whose views a person uses to guide their own attitudes and behaviour. BUS-220 described the types: membership groups a person belongs to, aspirational groups a person would like to belong to, and dissociative groups a person wants to avoid being associated with. In selling, reference groups explain why some products are judged by who else uses them. A law firm choosing boardroom furniture asks what other respected firms have. A young couple furnishing their first home looks at what their friends chose. A manufacturer considering RoomFlow asks which other manufacturers in the region use it.
Reference groups matter most for products that are visible to others and that are not necessities. Research by William Bearden and Michael Etzel in 1982 found that reference group influence on whether to buy a product, and on which brand to buy, was strongest for publicly consumed luxuries and weakest for privately consumed necessities. A mattress is private; a dining table where guests eat is public. A printer in the back office is private; a meeting room where clients sit is public. Sellers can use this to judge when examples of other customers will matter most.
Family and household decisions
Many consumer purchases are made by households, and each member may play a different role. Researchers describe five roles that also appear in business buying, as lesson 9 explains: the initiator who first suggests the purchase, the influencer whose views shape the choice, the decider who makes the final call, the buyer who pays or completes the purchase, and the user who lives with the product. One person may play several roles, and the roles are not always obvious from who speaks first.
| Role | Who | What Aiden should have learned |
|---|---|---|
| Initiator | The daughter, who noticed her mother's old table was failing | Why the family started looking now |
| Influencers | The daughter and her husband | What they thought about size and style |
| Decider and buyer | The mother | Her budget, taste and how many people she hosts |
| Users | The whole extended family at Sunday dinner | How many seats, how much wear, how easy to clean |
The safest habit is to ask rather than assume. Bev teaches associates to say early in the conversation, 'Who will be using this, and who else should we keep in mind?' The question is natural and polite, and it usually reveals the roles within a minute. It also avoids a mistake that can be offensive as well as costly: assuming that the man in a couple, the younger person in a family group or the person who speaks first is the one making the decision.
Cialdini's principles of influence
In his 1984 book Influence, Robert Cialdini described six principles that people use as shortcuts in deciding whether to agree to a request: reciprocity, commitment and consistency, social proof, authority, liking and scarcity. In a 2016 book he added a seventh, unity, meaning a sense of shared identity. Cialdini drew on laboratory research and on years of observing salespeople, fundraisers and advertisers. The principles describe real tendencies, though the size of each effect depends heavily on the situation, and some specific studies used to illustrate them have not replicated well.
| Principle | The tendency | Honest use | Line not to cross |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reciprocity | People feel obliged to return favours | Give genuinely useful help, such as a free print audit | Gifts designed to create a sense of debt |
| Commitment and consistency | People want to act consistently with what they have said | Summarize what the buyer said they need and check it | Trapping buyers with small yeses into a big one |
| Social proof | People look to what others like them do | Real reviews and references from similar customers | Fake reviews or invented customer numbers |
| Authority | People defer to credible expertise | Share real qualifications and evidence | Claimed expertise or certifications you do not have |
| Liking | People say yes to people they like | Be friendly, find real common ground | Fake friendship or flattery |
| Scarcity | Rare or ending opportunities seem more valuable | State real stock levels and real deadlines | False "only one left" or fake countdown timers |
| Unity | People favour those who share their identity | Mention genuine shared ties, such as a local business | Claiming an identity you do not share |
Social proof and reviews
Social proof is especially powerful when people are uncertain and when the others they observe seem similar to them. Solomon Asch's conformity experiments in the early 1950s showed that many people would agree with a clearly wrong answer about the length of lines when everyone else in the room did so. Later studies found the effect varies by culture and era, but the basic tendency to look to others has been confirmed many times.
Online reviews are the modern form of social proof, and they influence both consumer and business purchases. Research by the Spiegel Research Center at Northwestern University, published in 2017, found that a product with five reviews was nearly four times as likely to be bought as a product with none, and that purchase likelihood peaked for average ratings between about 4.0 and 4.7 stars rather than at a perfect 5.0. Buyers appear to find a few critical reviews more believable than uniform praise.
That finding is useful for honest sellers. Juniper & Pine does not hide its three-star reviews of a popular recliner; Bev trains associates to mention the most common complaint, that the footrest is short for tall people, and to suggest a different model to customers over about six feet tall. Customers trust the store more for it. Fake reviews are another matter. Canada's Competition Bureau has taken enforcement action against fake and incentivized reviews under the Competition Act, and SLS-150 covers the law in detail.
Word of mouth and opinion leaders
People trust recommendations from people they know more than almost any other source. In business markets, buyers ask colleagues at similar organizations, read industry forums and call references. In consumer markets, friends, family and neighbours shape choices, and so do online communities. Some people, called opinion leaders, have unusual influence within a group because of their knowledge, experience or position. A respected facilities manager at one school division may influence purchasing across several divisions; a well-known local interior designer may influence dozens of households.
Sellers cannot control word of mouth, but they can earn it. A customer who has a good experience and is asked, at the right moment, whether they would be willing to be a reference or write a review often agrees. Ridgeline asks satisfied customers to take one reference call a quarter at most and keeps a list so that no customer is overused. When Maya was trying to win the Keystone Grain Equipment meeting-room project, the most persuasive thing she did was arrange for Keystone's IT coordinator to speak with his counterpart at another manufacturer that had used RoomFlow for two years.
Business buyers also look for social proof in written form. Case studies that describe a similar customer's problem, what was installed and what changed afterwards give a buying committee something concrete to discuss. Peer review sites for business software let buyers read ratings from people in similar roles, and many public bodies ask suppliers for a list of comparable clients as part of a formal bid. Ridgeline keeps short case studies for each customer type it serves, written with each customer's approval, so that Maya can offer the one that matches the buyer in front of her.
Worked problem
Choosing the most useful reference
Maya can offer Halverson Law three references for a boardroom video system. Customer A is a large accounting firm with 300 staff in another province or state. Customer B is a 25-person law firm in the same city that installed the system a year ago. Customer C is a school division that installed 40 rooms. Halverson Law has 30 staff and worries most about client confidentiality on calls. Which reference should Maya offer first, and why?
Show solution
- Social proof is strongest when the other customer seems similar to the buyer.
- Customer B is closest: same profession, similar size, same city, and law firms share the confidentiality concern.
- Customer A is a professional firm but much larger and elsewhere; useful as a second reference on scale.
- Customer C is very different in purpose and size and would add little.
Answer: Offer Customer B first. A similar law firm that can speak to confidentiality on calls answers Halverson's main worry and is the most credible voice. Before giving the contact, Maya must ask Customer B's permission and agree on what they are comfortable discussing.
Culture and subculture
Culture is the set of values, beliefs, customs and ways of communicating that people learn from the groups they grow up in. It shapes how people make decisions, how they negotiate, how they show respect and how directly they say no. Canada is one of the most diverse countries in the world: Statistics Canada's 2021 census found that about 23 in 100 people were immigrants, the highest share in more than 150 years. Customers in any store or business may come from many cultural backgrounds, and so may the members of a buying committee.
Researchers have proposed frameworks for comparing cultures, such as Geert Hofstede's dimensions, which include individualism, power distance and uncertainty avoidance, and Edward Hall's distinction between high-context cultures, where much meaning is carried by relationships and setting, and low-context cultures, where meaning is stated explicitly. These frameworks are useful for noticing differences, but they describe average tendencies across whole countries, and critics have pointed out that individuals vary enormously within any culture. Using a framework to guess how a particular customer will behave is a form of stereotyping.
The practical approach is curiosity and flexibility rather than assumption. Pay attention to how the buyer communicates and adapt: some buyers want to get straight to the numbers, others want to build a relationship first; some say no directly, others signal it indirectly by saying a decision needs more time. When unsure, ask politely about the buyer's preferences, such as who else should be involved or how they like to receive information. Treating every customer with the same respect, while adjusting to how they prefer to communicate, is both good ethics and good business.
Online communities and influencers
Social media has created new reference groups and new opinion leaders. Home décor creators show room makeovers to large audiences, and buyers arrive at Juniper & Pine with screenshots of furniture they saw in a video. In business, buyers follow industry voices on professional networks and in podcasts. When an influencer is paid or given products, the law in both countries requires the relationship to be disclosed clearly. Canada's Competition Bureau and Ad Standards publish guidance on influencer disclosure, and sellers who work with influencers or ask customers for testimonials must follow those rules.
Common mistakes
MistakeThe person who speaks first is the decision maker.
InsteadAsk who will use the product and who else is involved; roles are often not obvious.
MistakeOnly five-star reviews help sales.
InsteadPurchase likelihood peaks for ratings around 4.0 to 4.7; some critical reviews increase credibility.
MistakeCultural frameworks tell you how a particular customer will behave.
InsteadThey describe broad averages; individuals vary, so observe, ask and adapt.
MistakeAny customer story counts as social proof.
InsteadReferences are most persuasive when the customer is similar to the buyer, and permission is needed.
Summary and key terms
- Reference groups influence purchases most for visible, non-essential products.
- Households have initiators, influencers, deciders, buyers and users; ask rather than assume who plays each role.
- Cialdini's principles are reciprocity, commitment and consistency, social proof, authority, liking, scarcity and unity.
- Each principle has an honest use and a manipulative one, and some uses are illegal.
- Reviews are powerful social proof; a few critical reviews make ratings more believable.
- Culture shapes communication and decisions, but frameworks describe averages, not individuals.
- Reference group
- A group whose views a person uses to guide their own attitudes and behaviour.
- Opinion leader
- A person with unusual influence on others' choices within a group.
- Social proof
- The tendency to look to what similar others do when uncertain.
- High-context culture
- A culture in which much meaning is carried by relationships and setting rather than words.
- Material connection
- A relationship, such as payment or free products, between an endorser and a seller that must be disclosed.
Practice problems
Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.
What should Aiden have asked the family looking for a dining table?
Show answer
Who will be using the table and who else should be kept in mind, which would have revealed that the mother was the decider and buyer.
Name Cialdini's seven principles.
Show answer
Reciprocity, commitment and consistency, social proof, authority, liking, scarcity and unity.
Why might a 4.5-star average sell better than a 5.0-star average?
Show answer
Buyers find a few critical reviews more believable than uniform praise.
What is the main risk of using a cultural framework with a single customer?
Show answer
It becomes stereotyping, because frameworks describe averages and individuals vary greatly.
Lesson quiz · 5 questions
Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.
Create a free account to save your progress, take quizzes and earn a certificate.